Membership for single golfers is $495 annually, $745 for couples, $165 for juniors under 18, and $798 for families. There are discounted rates for seniors. House memberships, which have no golfing privileges, are available at $110 for singles and $165 for couples. Proceeds from the club go back into maintaining the course. All membership prices given are prior to a New York. State tax of 8.625%.
To become a member, a membership application must be filled out and returned with a check for the appropriate membership category, payable to Shelter Island Country Club, in person or by mail at P.O. Box 852, 11965. The club welcomes non-members to play on weekdays, nine holes for $15; and $18 on weekends. The course and golf facilities are open from 7 a.m. until dusk April through October. The restaurant will be seating customers until 8:30 pm during the week and until 9:30 pm on the weekend.